In nineteen ninety-eight, Raymond Nickerson published a sweeping review in the Review of General Psychology on confirmation bias, which he called "a ubiquitous phenomenon in many guises." His survey showed the bias operating everywhere: we seek information that confirms what we believe, interpret ambiguous evidence as support, and remember our hits while forgetting our misses. Scientists do it, judges do it, and ordinary people do it daily. Nickerson argued the bias is not a single flaw but a family of related tendencies, woven into how attention, memory, and reasoning work, and he traced its consequences from the laboratory to the courtroom to the voting booth. The review's power is cumulative: case after case, the same pattern, until the reader must confront it in themselves. Everward includes it under "What is truth?" and "How should we disagree?" as the empirical backbone of the Covenant's demand that we stay open to being wrong. If the mind's default is to confirm itself, then humility is not a mood. It is a discipline.