Everward Library · Week 8 of ten
How should we disagree?
One of the ten questions the Everward curriculum is built around.
“A book’s presence in the Everward Library means its ideas are worth encountering. It does not mean Everward endorses every idea in the book.” Everward Library principle
This is the most practical conversation in the sequence, and the one the others depend on. Mill's case for letting even false opinions circulate meets Ibsen's portrait of the truth-teller a community destroys, Tocqueville's warnings about the tyranny of the majority, and the psychological research on confirmation bias and motivated reasoning that explains why disagreement feels like attack. The conversation should produce norms, not just insights: how will this group handle its own disagreements? Facilitators should enforce the norms early and visibly — steelman before you rebut, separate the person from the claim, and let the quietest voice finish.
Works that ask this question
Presence here means an idea is worth encountering — not that Everward endorses every idea in the work.
- An Enemy of the People How should we disagree?What is truth?What makes a good society? ReadListenDownload
- An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding What is truth?What are we responsible for?How should we disagree? ReadListenDownload
- Apology What is truth?How should we disagree? ReadListenDownload
- Confirmation Bias: A Ubiquitous Phenomenon in Many Guises What is truth?How should we disagree? ReadListenDownload
- Democracy in America, Vol. I What makes a good society?How should we disagree?Why do we need one another? ReadListenDownload
- Everward Core Meditations What makes a good life?What are we responsible for?How is character formed?How should we disagree?What gives life purpose? ReadListenDownload
- On Liberty How should we disagree?What makes a good society?What gives every human being dignity? ReadListenDownload
- The Case for Motivated Reasoning What is truth?How should we disagree? ReadListenDownload
- The U.S. Constitution and Bill of Rights What makes a good society?How should we disagree?What gives every human being dignity? ReadListenDownload
The other nine questions
- Week 1What makes a good life?
- Week 2What makes a good society?
- Week 3What is truth?
- Week 4What gives every human being dignity?
- Week 5What are we responsible for?
- Week 6How is character formed?
- Week 7Why do we need one another?
- Week 9What do justice, mercy and forgiveness require?
- Week 10What gives life purpose?