Everward Library · Week 9 of ten
What do justice, mercy and forgiveness require?
One of the ten questions the Everward curriculum is built around.
“A book’s presence in the Everward Library means its ideas are worth encountering. It does not mean Everward endorses every idea in the book.” Everward Library principle
Justice, mercy, and forgiveness pull in different directions, and this conversation refuses to dissolve the tension. Hugo and Dostoevsky stage the collision between what is deserved and what redeems; the Thirteenth Amendment and the UDHR show law trying to encode justice after atrocity; Douglass and Du Bois testify to what justice delayed costs. Participants will disagree about whether forgiveness can be required, whether mercy undermines justice, and who has standing to forgive. Facilitators should keep the conversation concrete — abstract theories of justice are cheap; cases are expensive — and should never pressure anyone toward forgiveness as the 'right' answer.
Works that ask this question
Presence here means an idea is worth encountering — not that Everward endorses every idea in the work.
- A Christmas Carol What do justice, mercy and forgiveness require?What makes a good life?How is character formed? ReadListenDownload
- Les Misérables What do justice, mercy and forgiveness require?What makes a good society?What gives every human being dignity? ReadListenDownload
- Magna Carta (1215) What makes a good society?What gives every human being dignity?What do justice, mercy and forgiveness require? ReadListenDownload
- Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass What gives every human being dignity?What do justice, mercy and forgiveness require?What makes a good society? ReadListenDownload
- The Brothers Karamazov What gives every human being dignity?What do justice, mercy and forgiveness require? ReadListenDownload
- The Qur'an — J. M. Rodwell's 1861 English translation (historical) What gives life purpose?What do justice, mercy and forgiveness require?What gives every human being dignity? ReadListenDownload
- The Republic What makes a good society?What is truth?What do justice, mercy and forgiveness require? ReadListenDownload
- The Souls of Black Folk What gives every human being dignity?What makes a good society?What do justice, mercy and forgiveness require? ReadListenDownload
- The Thirteenth Amendment (1865) What gives every human being dignity?What do justice, mercy and forgiveness require? ReadListenDownload
- The Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948) What gives every human being dignity?What makes a good society?What do justice, mercy and forgiveness require? ReadListenDownload
- The World English Bible (Protestant 66-book edition) What gives life purpose?What do justice, mercy and forgiveness require?What gives every human being dignity? ReadListenDownload